The CCF Just Issued Seven New Decisions – Key Takeaways for Lawyers and Targets of Red Notices and Diffusions
By Ariel Rawls and Sandra Grossman
The Commission for the Control of INTERPOL’s Files (CCF) finally gave lawyers and their clients some new, much-needed guidance and insight into how and when it will delete Red Notices and Diffusions in favor of individuals who argue they have been unjustly targeted. In November, the CCF, the independent body responsible for reviewing requests to access, correct, or delete data in INTERPOL’s files, issued seven well-reasoned decisions applying INTERPOL’s Rules and Constitution. These decisions provide useful insight into which legal strategies and arguments may be most effective when seeking deletion.
The CCF has long made clear that it is neither a court nor an investigative body. It does not determine guilt, retry criminal cases, or independently investigate the allegations underlying a notice or diffusion. Its task is to assess whether information in INTERPOL’s files complies with its internal rules. The new decisions do not alter that role. They do, however, offer a useful look at how the CCF applies its standards in practice. Several themes emerge: arguments seeking to delete data simply based on technical grounds, like, for example, an extradition denial or on statute of limitation ground, will not necessarily negate the purposes of police cooperation; highlighting parallel human rights filings or decisions, as well as treatment of co-defendants, continues to carry significant weight for the CCF; lawyers should scrutinize the factual summary provided by a country’s National Central Bureau (NCB), identify gaps in its description of the individual’s alleged role, and submit documentation addressing those gaps; and arguments concerning due process and human rights violations should be supported by evidence specific to the applicant’s case, rather than general criticisms of a country’s legal system.
This article examines the key lessons from the CCF’s latest decisions and explains what they mean for individuals seeking to challenge Red Notices and Diffusions and the lawyers representing them. It highlights the arguments that may support a Request for Deletion, the types of evidence that can strengthen a challenge, and the issues lawyers should consider when assessing the information submitted by a requesting country.
Lesson 1: The Red Notice or Diffusion must adequately describe the individual’s alleged role in the commission of the alleged crime
Several of the new decisions address a recurring problem with Red Notices and Diffusions: the NCB that requested the notice or diffusion provides a seemingly detailed account of an alleged criminal scheme, without explaining how the individual named in the notice personally participated in it.
Decision 2026-07 provides a clear example. The Red Notice described a large-scale operation involving the alleged smuggling of frozen goods through a company owned by the applicant. It identified the volume and value of the goods, the period during which the smuggling allegedly occurred, and the profits generated by evading customs duties. The authorities characterized the applicant as the head of the operation and claimed that his employees carried out the smuggling at his direction.
But the Notice did not explain what illicit activities the applicant himself had actually been involved in, or his individual involvement. The NCB’s description simply stated that he had “instructed others” to commit the crime, without explaining what he had instructed. The NCB failed in its response to a CCF request to identify the instructions he allegedly gave, the employees who received them, or the specific conduct he directed. The CCF noted that “the mere assertion that he instructed the commission of the crime is alone insufficient to constitute concrete information linking him to the activity in question.” Decision 2026-07, para. 27. The Commission ordered deletion.
Conversely, Decision 2026-01 illustrates what type of data or information of criminal conduct the CCF considers sufficient. That case involved allegations that the applicant abused his position in two related companies to orchestrate the transfer of real estate assets from one company to another at approximately one-third of their market value. The applicant was a member of the board of directors of the company that lost the assets and also served as the general director of the company that acquired them. The NCB’s allegations went further than simply identifying his corporate positions. They described his alleged role in arranging the appointment of a deputy general director, securing approval of the transaction, and misleading other company representatives about the terms of the sale. The authorities alleged that the assets were later transferred to another company under the applicant’s control.
The CCF found that the applicant’s arguments simply describing the underlying event as a corporate dispute was insufficient because the Diffusion provided a “comprehensive account of the date, manner, and location of the alleged conduct.” Decision 2026-01, para 22. It also considered an investigator’s statement submitted by the NCB. That statement corroborated the allegations and supplied additional details about the applicant’s corporate roles, the transaction price, the property’s market value, and the alleged financial benefit. The Commission found that the NCB had provided “adequate and specific information demonstrating a plausible connection between the Applicant and the alleged offence(s), indicating his possible individual involvement therein.” Decision 2026-01, para. 21.
Read together, these decisions show that the CCF carefully examines the connection between the alleged criminal activity and the individual named in the notice. A detailed description of a criminal operation will not necessarily satisfy that “coherence” requirement if the applicant’s role remains conclusory and may lead to deletion of the notice or diffusion. Attorneys are well advised to focus on whether the factual summary provided accurately describes an Applicant’s individual conduct. And, if it doesn’t, they must submit evidence and arguments demonstrating a different narrative or account of the facts.
AT A GLANCE: 2026 DECISIONS ADDRESSING LESSON 1
| Decision | Outcome | Provisions relied on |
| 2026-01 | Corporate-dispute framing rejected; Diffusion retained NCB prevailed | RPD Arts. 10, 12, 35, 97(1)–(2), 99(2)(a); RPD Art. 81(3)(d) (applied mutatis mutandis to Diffusions); IPSG criminal-activity-description standard; Constitution, Art. 2(1) considered for due process allegations. |
| 2026-04 | Red Notice deleted Applicant prevailed | RPD Arts. 12, 83(2)(b)(i); IPSG criminal-activity-description standard |
| 2026-05 | Diffusion deleted Applicant prevailed | RPD Arts. 12, 99(2) (central), 35, 37(h); Constitution. Art. 31; IPCQ policy (25 Aug. 2023). Art. 83 applies to Red Notices, not Diffusions |
| 2026-07 | Red Notice deleted Applicant prevailed | RPD Arts. 12, 83(2)(b)(i); IPSG criminal-activity-description standard |
Lesson 2: The fact that a Red Notice or Diffusion arises from a contractual dispute does not, by itself, establish that the proceedings are purely civil
Decision 2026-01 also addresses another argument frequently raised in Requests for Deletion of data in INTERPOL’s systems: that the underlying proceedings concern a commercial or contractual dispute rather than a criminal offense. The applicant argued that the real estate transaction in question was indeed lawful, arguing that the property was held as collateral under a guarantee and was sold after the debtor failed to meet its contractual obligations. In his view, the criminal proceedings were being used to advance a corporate dispute.
The CCF did not accept that the commercial context, by itself, made the Diffusion improper. Again, it focused on the individualized conduct described by the authorities and found that the allegations went beyond a disagreement over contractual performance. The domestic authorities had accused the applicant of abusing his managerial position, arranging for a related individual to execute the transaction, misleading company representatives about the terms of the sale, and transferring company assets at a substantial undervalue for the benefit of another company he directed.
The Commission found that the facts presented adequately described alleged criminal conduct under domestic law rather than a mere contractual dispute. It also made clear that determining the actual terms of the agreement and whether the transaction was lawful under that agreement fell within the jurisdiction of the domestic courts, not the CCF. Decision 2026-01, paras. 25–30.
The decision does not prevent lawyers or applicants from arguing that a criminal allegation is, at its core, a contractual or civil dispute that does not warrant publication in INTERPOL’s files. In fact, the CCF has previously made clear that administrative and commercial disputes generally do not constitute a serious ordinary law crime suitable for publication in INTERPOL’s systems. See Specific Offenses for Which Red Notices May Not Be Issued (2022). However, the decision makes clear that simply characterizing a case as contractual, civil, or administrative, without more, is generally insufficient.
AT A GLANCE: 2026 DECISIONS ADDRESSING LESSON 2
| Decision | Outcome | Provisions relied on |
| 2026-01 | Corporate-dispute framing rejected; Diffusion retained NCB prevailed | RPD Arts. 12, 35, 97(1)–(2), 99(2)(a); Constitution, Art. 2(1) considered |
Lesson 3: The CCF does not retry criminal cases, but it must assess whether the information supporting a Red Notice or Diffusion is sufficiently specific and substantiated
In this latest set of decisions, the CCF repeatedly stresses the limits of its mandate. In Decision 2026-01, it reiterated that “[t]he Commission is not empowered to conduct investigations, assess the credibility or weight of evidence, or determine the merits of the underlying criminal case.” Decision 2026-01, para. 21. It does not decide whether the prosecution’s evidence is sufficient to convict or whether the applicant is innocent or guilty of the underlying illicit conduct. Rather, key to a successful deletion are arguments focused on whether the information submitted to INTERPOL by a particular NCB satisfies INTERPOL’s Constitution and the Rules on the Processing of Data. Decision 2026-04 illustrates how that review works. The applicant in that case was a lawyer who provided legal services to individuals accused of operating a cryptocurrency-related pyramid scheme. He was also the landlord of a property leased to their company. The Red Notice alleged that he had received funds from one of the company’s directors and was a beneficiary of the alleged scheme. The applicant explained that the payments were for legal services and rent. He supported his account with confirmation letters from two clients and a copy of the lease agreement.
The NCB maintained that the funds originated from the pyramid scheme and that the applicant benefited financially from the criminal activity. Nevertheless, the NCB failed to provide the arrest warrant underlying the Red Notice. It also failed to explain how the alleged pyramid scheme operated, how the funds received by the company constituted proceeds of crime, or how the applicant’s receipt of payment amounted to money laundering. The CCF requested clarification several times, but the NCB did not respond.
The Commission found that it could not verify whether the judicial information was accurate and consistent with the underlying arrest warrant or see how the transfer of funds, in and of itself, established the existence of criminal conduct. Without those details, the CCF could not identify a concrete connection between the applicant’s conduct and the offense, ordering deletion under Articles 12 and 83(2)(b)(i) of the Rules on the Processing of Data. Decision 2026-04, paras. 19–24. Critically, the CCF did not rule on whether the applicant was guilty or innocent of the crime alleged, concluding only that the NCB failed to provide the information necessary to support the allegation that the applicant committed money laundering.
This is an important distinction for applicants and lawyers. A Request for Deletion need not ask the Commission to resolve every factual dispute in the criminal case. It should identify what the notice alleges, what the supporting documents actually establish, and what essential information is missing. Where the requesting country cannot explain how the alleged conduct satisfies the elements of the offense, that deficiency may itself establish non-compliance with INTERPOL’s Rules on the Processing of Data.
AT A GLANCE: 2026 DECISIONS ADDRESSING LESSON 3
| Decision | Outcome | Provisions relied on |
| 2026-01 | Corporate-dispute framing rejected; Diffusion retained NCB prevailed | RPD Arts. 12, 35, 97(1)–(2), 99(2)(a); Constitution, Art. 2(1) considered |
| 2026-04 | Red Notice deleted Applicant prevailed | RPD Arts. 12, 83(2)(b)(i); IPSG criminal-activity-description standard |
Lesson 4: Findings from other courts and human rights bodies can strengthen a Request to Delete a Red Notice or Diffusion when the findings relate directly to the applicant’s case; technical arguments on their own, will not carry sufficient weight
Another significant theme in the 2026 decisions is the weight the CCF may give to findings from other courts, particularly when they document human rights or due process violations relevant to the applicant’s circumstances. Decisions from foreign courts and international human rights bodies can provide important support for deletion of data under Article 2 of INTERPOL’s Constitution, which requires INTERPOL to act within “the spirit of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.” This mandates in favor of applicants and their attorneys seeking to file complimentary or parallel complaints in specialized human rights-based bodies, such as regional mechanisms and/or the United Nations.
In Decision 2026-02, the applicant was convicted in absentia of fraud over a commercial transaction involving electronic components, while living outside the requesting country. He argued that he was not informed of the proceedings and had no meaningful opportunity to defend himself or appeal the conviction. The NCB maintained that the proceedings and notice were valid and suggested that he should have learned about the charges through personal connections. Nevertheless, the record showed that the applicant was indeed living and working abroad and that the NCB failed to establish that it had diligently attempted to contact him before proceeding in his absence.
The CCF considered the applicant’s right to notice in light of Article 14(3) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). It recalled that the right to be promptly informed of criminal charges is a prerequisite to the effective exercise of the rights of the defense. Decision 2026-02, para. 19. The Commission also considered the applicant’s inability to participate in the proceedings or appeal his conviction.
Importantly, the applicant also submitted a decision from a foreign court refusing extradition because of risks to his human rights, including concerns about his right to a fair trial and the conditions in which he might be detained. The CCF explained that national extradition decisions based on individualized human rights risks “may be regarded as additional evidence supporting the Applicant’s claims of non-compliance with Article 2 of INTERPOL’s Constitution.” Decision 2026-02, para. 23. The Commission considered the foreign court’s specific findings alongside the deficiencies in notification and the applicant’s inability to appeal. It ultimately found that the circumstances raised concerns about compliance with Article 2 and ordered deletion. Decision 2026-02, paras. 19–25.
Decision 2026-03 provides another example of parallel court findings holding significant weight with the CCF, this time involving findings of torture concerning co-defendants in the same criminal proceedings. The applicant argued that the prosecution relied on confessions from his co-defendants obtained through torture. In support, he submitted a judgment from a regional human rights court in proceedings brought by several co-defendants. That court had found violations concerning torture and inhuman or degrading treatment. Although the applicant was not a party to that case, the findings concerned the same investigation and the co-defendants whose confessions were used as evidence against him.
The CCF explained that, in conducting its review under Article 2 of INTERPOL’s Constitution, it considers relevant information to determine whether an applicant has demonstrated the likelihood of a “flagrant denial of due process.” Decision 2026-03, para. 25. Applying that approach, the Commission found that the regional court’s judgment supported the applicant’s concerns. It specifically noted that the judgment, although not directly about the applicant, supported his allegation that the co-defendants’ confessions had been obtained under torture. The Commission concluded that the judgment provided substantial grounds for the applicant’s concerns and indicated serious risks associated with being tried on the basis of that evidence. Decision 2026-03, para. 29.
The Commission went further, describing the regional court’s decision as an “authoritative assessment not only of the alleged violation of the applicant’s due process rights, but also of the potential human rights violations to which he could be exposed if extradited.” Decision 2026-03, para. 30. It ultimately ordered deletion on that basis.
Together, these decisions establish that findings from other proceedings can carry significant weight in a CCF request when they directly relate to the applicant’s case. An extradition court’s findings about fair trial or detention risks may support deletion, as may a regional human rights court’s findings concerning co-defendants whose evidence was used against the applicant. Conversely, general criticisms of a country’s legal system or human rights record are insufficient to establish an Article 2 violation. See CCF Decision No. 4 (2025), paras. 33–34. Attorneys and applicants must provide, whenever possible, specific judicial findings establishing “flagrant violations” of their due process rights.
AT A GLANCE: 2026 DECISIONS ADDRESSING LESSON 4
| Decision | Outcome | Provisions relied on |
| 2026-02 | Red Notice deleted Applicant prevailed | Constitution, Art. 2(1); RPD Art. 11; UDHR Arts. 5, 7, 9, 10, 11; ICCPR Art. 14(3) |
| 2026-03 | Red Notice deleted Applicant prevailed | Constitution, Art. 2(1); RPD Arts. 11, 12, 34(1), 34(3); Repository of Practice on Arts. 2 and 3 |
Lesson 5: A denied extradition request does not automatically require INTERPOL to delete a Red Notice or Diffusion
An extradition refusal can be important evidence in a Request for Deletion, but the Commission’s 2026 decisions make clear that its significance depends on the grounds for the refusal, and not simply technical or procedural justifications.
In Decision 2026-06, the applicant was the subject of a Red Notice for drug trafficking. He was arrested in another country, and the requesting authorities promptly submitted a formal extradition request. The requested country ultimately refused extradition because the prosecution was time-barred under its domestic statute of limitations.
The CCF found that this was a technical obstacle specific to the bilateral extradition relationship. Other INTERPOL member countries might apply different limitation periods and remain able to cooperate. The Commission also considered the requesting country’s efforts to pursue the case. The authorities had promptly sought extradition, provided renewed assurances, and pursued mutual legal assistance. Those steps demonstrated a continuing interest in the prosecution and reasonable efforts to advance the case. The CCF therefore maintained the Red Notice. It did, however, require the extradition refusal to be recorded in an addendum so that other NCBs would be informed of the decision. Decision 2026-06, paras. 20–25.
Decision 2026-05 involved a different type of extradition refusal and a different result. The applicant was the subject of a Diffusion concerning alleged offenses that included abuse of position, money laundering, corruption, bribery, fraud, and forgery. The underlying allegations related to customs declarations for shipments of used clothing and spare parts. The applicant was described as an agent for companies involved in transit operations between two countries. But the Diffusion did not explain whether he had personally submitted fraudulent customs declarations or had simply benefited from the alleged conduct of others.
The CCF found that the description was “extremely vague” and that it could not identify the acts underlying the individual charges. Decision 2026-05, para 20. It could not determine the applicant’s alleged conduct or understand how the facts amounted to the various offenses listed in the Diffusion. The Commission also considered that a court in another country had refused extradition because the requesting authorities had failed to provide a sufficiently clear description of the alleged criminal activity. The NCB did not provide substantive answers to the CCF’s repeated requests for information about the extradition proceedings.
The CCF expressly recognized that Article 83 of the RPD applies to Red Notices, not Diffusions. But it explained that the related data-quality and international police cooperation requirements under Articles 12, 35, 37(h), and 99(2) still require a clear and coherent description of criminal activity and the individual’s alleged role. It treated the extradition court’s findings as additional evidence supporting the applicant’s deletion request. The Commission also considered the prior deletion of a Diffusion concerning a co-defendant in similar circumstances. It ultimately ordered deletion. Decision 2026-05, paras. 18–27.
The different results in these decisions are ultimately based on why extradition of the applicant was denied – whether for a technical or substantive violation. In Decision 2026-06, the extradition refusal resulted from a statute of limitations that applied in one country but not in another. In Decision 2026-05, the extradition court’s concerns went to the substance of the allegations themselves. The same lack of detail that undermined extradition also prevented the CCF from determining whether the Diffusion complied with INTERPOL’s rules.
These decisions demonstrate why lawyers should obtain and carefully analyze the actual extradition decision rather than simply report that extradition was denied. The court’s reasoning may reveal a defect in the underlying allegations, identify human-rights concerns, or reflect a technical obstacle that has little bearing on INTERPOL compliance. The distinction can determine whether the decision provides meaningful support for deletion. In any case, applicants and lawyers should provide a copy of the decision to the CCF and explain its basis.
AT A GLANCE: 2026 DECISIONS ADDRESSING LESSON 5
| Decision | Outcome | Provisions relied on |
| 2026-05 | Diffusion deleted Applicant prevailed | RPD Arts. 12, 99(2), 35, 37(h); Constitution, Art. 31; IPCQ policy (25 Aug. 2023). |
| 2026-06 | Red Notice retained; extradition denial added to INTERPOL’s files NCB prevailed | RPD Arts. 10, 51, 82, 84(b), 87; Constitution, Art. 31; GA Res. AGN/53/RES/7 (1984) |
Lesson 6: NCBs must adequately respond to the CCF’s questions and requests for information
When considering an applicant’s Request for Deletion, the CCF often seeks additional information from the NCB that requested the notice or diffusion. The 2026 decisions show that an NCB’s failure to respond meaningfully to the CCF’s requests for information, or its decision to repeat information already in INTERPOL’s files, can leave significant compliance issues unresolved and result in deletion of the notice or diffusion. While lawyers and applicants cannot rely on NCB’s failures to respond, they can anticipate as to whether and how a particular NCB will respond and frame their legal strategies around this dynamic. For example, they may argue that a factual summary is incorrect or deficient, with the knowledge that the NCB will be unable to provide specific evidence or arguments.
In Decision 2026-04, the CCF repeatedly asked the NCB to provide the arrest warrant and clarify the alleged pyramid scheme, the applicant’s connection to it, and his possible role in laundering the funds. The NCB did not provide the warrant or respond to the CCF’s requests. As a result, the CCF could not verify the judicial basis for the Red Notice or determine how the applicant’s receipt of funds amounted to money laundering.
Decision 2026-07 presented a related problem. The CCF asked the NCB to provide more information about the applicant’s alleged role in the smuggling operation. The NCB’s response largely repeated the original assertion that the applicant had instructed others to carry out the smuggling. It did not identify the instructions, the individuals who received them, or the applicant’s specific actions.
The NCB also described the applicant’s conviction as final but submitted a court decision concerning only his co-defendants. The applicant was mentioned briefly in that decision, which suggested that he had been tried separately. Despite repeated requests, the NCB did not clarify whether the applicant had been convicted in separate proceedings or whether the conviction was final. The CCF also questioned whether the arrest warrant recorded in the Red Notice remained accurate because the NCB claimed that the applicant had already been convicted. It was therefore unclear whether he was wanted for prosecution or to serve a sentence. Those deficiencies prevented the CCF from confirming compliance with Articles 12 and 83(2)(b)(i) of the RPD, and it ordered deletion. Decision 2026-07, paras. 21–29.
These decisions provide significant insight and confirmations of the “behind the scenes” processes employed by the CCF, highlighting a positive fact: that the CCF’s consultation with NCBs is not a mere formality, and that it expects the NCBs to comply with its obligations to ensure the quality of data in INTERPOL’s files and to respond to the CCF’s queries. At least in some cases, the CCF needs a coherent and adequately supported record to determine whether the data can remain in INTERPOL’s files.
AT A GLANCE: 2026 DECISIONS ADDRESSING LESSON 6
| Decision | Outcome | Provisions relied on |
| 2026-04 | Red Notice deleted Applicant prevailed | RPD Arts. 12, 83(2)(b)(i); IPSG criminal-activity-description standard |
| 2026-07 | Red Notice deleted Applicant prevailed | RPD Arts. 12, 83(2)(b)(i); IPSG criminal-activity-description standard |
Key Takeaways
The latest decisions offer an important reminder that challenging an INTERPOL notice or diffusion requires more than pointing to flaws in a criminal allegation. The focus must be on the information INTERPOL is being asked to circulate and whether that information meets its governing Rules and Constitution. As these decisions demonstrate, even seemingly detailed allegations may fall short when they do not clearly establish an individual’s role or when the requesting authorities cannot substantiate key aspects of their case.
GYH attorneys regularly utilize and implement the key takeaways and lessons from these Decisions and others to attack and delete erroneous or persecutory INTERPOL data. We examine the notice, the supporting evidence, and the procedural history, while identifying gaps and inconsistencies in the requesting country’s account. We also look beyond the CCF process when additional support is warranted. This may include pursuing remedies before international human rights bodies such as the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR), the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention (WGAD), the UN Committee Against Torture (CAT), or the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). Where appropriate, we engage criminal law experts to analyze the charges, assess the underlying proceedings, and identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s theory under local law and, where applicable, egregious violations of due process guarantees. We also anticipate explanations or evidence the NCB may submit and develop responses to address them.
GYH takes a comprehensive approach to present the CCF with a clear, well-supported basis for finding that the data should be conclusively deleted. The 2026 decisions reinforce why that careful and comprehensive approach matters.
www.grossmanyoung.com | info@grossmanyoung.com | (240) 403-0913 | (301) 917-6900
*Disclaimer: This information is presented for the purposes of general education and does not constitute legal advice.